Transgender rightsPrison health care

Hormone treatment in federal prisons

What happens when prisons interrupt treatment, and what the court record shows.

12 November 202611 min read79 numbered posts · 74 linked sourcesRead on Bluesky ↗Read on Threads ↗

2/79Link copied

Treatment decisions belong to the patient, in prison too. A prison sentence takes away a person's liberty. It does not take away their medical care or give the state a veto over their body.

10/79Link copied

The prison system gives four reasons: the evidence is weak, hormones carry long-term risks, trans prisoners attract violence, and care gives prisoners an incentive to harm themselves. The record answers each one, and none justifies taking anyone's medicine away.

27/79Link copied

Its expert calls a 2011 Swedish study (Dhejne et al.) "unfavorable." That study compared patients with the general population, not with untreated patients. Its authors wrote: "Things might have been even worse without sex reassignment."

Sourcejournals.plos.orgplosone/article
41/79Link copied

A relative risk means little without its baseline. Breast cancer is rare in men, so twenty-two times a rare rate can still be a small absolute risk. Presenting the multiple alone as proof of a large risk is a textbook statistical error.

42/79Link copied

A 2023 meta-analysis (Corso et al.) gives both: trans women's breast cancer incidence was 22.5 times cis men's (95% CI 5.54 to 91.8), and 0.30 times cis women's (95% CI 0.22 to 0.42), 70% lower. No one cites that to deny estrogen to cis women.

Sourcepubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov36789830
48/79Link copied

The expert's other risks are no stronger. He counts 163 FDA reports with no patient total. Among trans U.S. veterans, hormone therapy was not tied to more cardiovascular disease: HR 0.99 (0.89-1.09) in trans women, 0.89 (0.80-0.98) in trans men.

Sourcepubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov40601199
78/79Link copied

What should be done: withdraw Bureau of Prisons policy 5260.01 and stop fighting the court order. Provide hormone care to every patient who seeks it, new or current, and stop it only when the patient chooses.

79/79Link copied

Restore care to anyone already tapered off. Protect trans prisoners by stopping the people who attack them, not by taking away their medicine.

End of thread · Back to the first post