Transgender rightsViolence and stigma

Violence and the stigma against trans people

Why individual acts of violence do not justify treating an entire group as dangerous.

16 November 20267 min read43 numbered posts · 38 linked sourcesRead on Bluesky ↗Read on Threads ↗

5/43Link copied

A crime belongs to the person who committed it. Blaming people who share a label with a suspect, or with a suspect's roommate, protects no one and endangers people who did nothing. Anyone can be handed a label, so that rule protects everyone.

24/43Link copied

The Supreme Court: liability "may not be imposed merely because an individual belonged to a group, some members of which committed acts of violence." It requires proof that the individual "held a specific intent to further those illegal aims."

Sourcetile.loc.govusrep458886.pdf, p. 35
31/43Link copied

The administration's own ATF wrote in May 2026 that federal law does not disarm those "simply 'afflicted with mental illness,'" which "could cover over 23% of the adult population." It takes an adjudication or involuntary commitment, not a diagnosis.

Sourcegovinfo.gov2026-09156.pdf, p. 4
35/43Link copied

Trans people are more often the ones harmed. In the CDC's 2023 survey, 40.1% of trans high school students had been bullied at school in the past year, against 20.3% of cis girls and 14.8% of cis boys; 25.3% missed school because they felt unsafe.

Sourcecdc.govmmwr/volumes/73/su/su7304a6.htm
38/43Link copied

Then the government stopped counting. The Bureau of Justice Statistics cut its survey's gender identity questions. Asked by the Williams Institute and 40+ groups to restore them, it cited an executive order: "these questions will not be added back."

Sourcereginfo.govpublic/do/DownloadDocument
39/43Link copied

After cutting gender identity from its crime-victim survey, the Justice Department offered $1 million in October 2026 to study gender dysphoria, its treatment and "the perpetration of violence." Its notice says the evidence "is limited."

Sourceojp.govnij-2026-172802.pdf, p. 3
40/43Link copied

The federal survey that found trans people facing 2.5 to 4.4 times the violence can no longer count them, while officials point to trans people as a source of violence. Why stop measuring the harm while widening the suspicion?

41/43Link copied

What the evidence supports: investigate violence, threats, plans and material support, never views, identity or relationships. Withdraw the "radically pro-transgender" label and review any list or file built on it.

42/43Link copied

Tie no gun rule to gender identity or diagnosis; keep the requirement of a court finding or formal commitment. Handle danger one person at a time, through threat assessment, reporting and court orders. Restore the survey questions.

43/43Link copied

Pin no identity or ideology on a suspect before investigators establish it, and none on a whole group at all. Every attack has an attacker with a name, and the blame belongs there. Trans people are owed what everyone is owed: to answer only for their own acts.

End of thread · Back to the first post