After Charlie Kirk was shot in September 2025, posts falsely identified a Seattle trans woman as the shooter, and a former Trump aide shared her photo. "People were saying that they were going to find me and they were going to kill me," she said.
Sourcekuow.orgstories/conservatives-falsely-accused-her-of-assassinating-charlie-kirk-it-started-with-dr-pepper-jokesTransgender rightsViolence and stigma
Violence and the stigma against trans people
Why individual acts of violence do not justify treating an entire group as dangerous.
She recalled one comment: if the FBI did not get her, "we have to take this into our own hands." She had nothing to do with the killing.
Sourcekuow.orgstories/conservatives-falsely-accused-her-of-assassinating-charlie-kirk-it-started-with-dr-pepper-jokesUtah's charges name one defendant. The only person the record describes as "transitioning genders" is his roommate, who received messages from him about the shooting and "provided those messages to police."
Sourcejustthenews.comTJR Information.pdf, p. 7After Uvalde in 2022, Rep. Paul Gosar tweeted, then deleted, the unfounded claims that the shooter was trans and in the U.S. illegally. A New York trans woman's photo spread as the shooter's, and she got messages saying she was the shooter.
Sourcenbcchicago.comnews/national-international/horrifying-conspiracy-theories-swirl-around-texas-shooting/2842454A crime belongs to the person who committed it. Blaming people who share a label with a suspect, or with a suspect's roommate, protects no one and endangers people who did nothing. Anyone can be handed a label, so that rule protects everyone.
Officials cite numbers that do not hold. On CNN in August 2025, White House counterterrorism director Sebastian Gorka claimed "seven mass shootings involving people of transgender nature" in "just a couple of years": "inordinately high."
Sourceprod.transcripts.cnn.comshow/sotu/date/2025-08-31/segment/01FactCheck.org checked his seven. In Philadelphia, local officials said the suspect "is not transgender," despite false claims. In Perry, Iowa, the shooter's gender identity "hasn't been established." His cases span 2018 to 2025.
Sourcefactcheck.org2025/09/few-mass-shooters-have-been-transgenderThe Gun Violence Archive counted 5,748 mass shootings from January 2013 to mid-September 2025. Its founder counted five confirmed trans shooters, under 0.1% of those shootings, or "as high as eight" with unverified cases, about 0.14%.
Sourcefactcheck.org2025/09/few-mass-shooters-have-been-transgenderAbout 2.8 million Americans aged 13 and older are trans. Even if all eight cases were confirmed, that is one in 350,000 of them. A label shared by millions tells you nothing about any one of them.
Sourcewilliamsinstitute.law.ucla.edupress/trans-pop-estimates-press-releaseNo one is disarmed or put on a watch list for being a man, though 98% of the shooters in the Violence Project's database of public mass shootings since 1966 were male. No one should be. Trans people deserve the same fairness.
Sourcetheviolenceproject.orgdatabases/mass-shootersIn that database, one of 201 mass shooters from 1966 to 2024 was trans: the 2023 Nashville school shooter. Even there, the record points away from identity.
Sourcefactcheck.org2025/09/few-mass-shooters-have-been-transgenderNashville police concluded that the motive was "notoriety." The shooter studied the Columbine killers and "considered them worthy of emulation."
Sourcenbcnews.comnews/us-news/nashville-school-shooter-sought-fame-2023-attack-left-6-dead-report-fi-rcna199327After the 2025 Annunciation church shooting, Minneapolis's police chief cited the shooter's "deranged fascination with previous mass shootings" and said the shooter "fantasized about the plans of other mass shooters."
Sourcefox6now.comnews/annunciation-school-shooting-minneapolis-minnesota-suspect-shooterThe Secret Service tells police, from 25 years of research: "There is no specific demographic profile of an attacker." Those who pose a risk "often communicate their intentions to those around them."
Sourcesecretservice.govBehavioral-Threat-Assessment-Units-A-Guide-for-State-and-Local-Law-Enforcement-to-Prevent-Targeted-Violence.pdf, p. 12That is how attacks are stopped. In 63 of 67 school attack plots the Secret Service studied, the plotters told others what they meant to do, and 50 were detected solely because of what they communicated.
Sourcesecretservice.govUSSS Averting Targeted School Violence.2021.03.pdf, p. 27Heritage's push for an FBI terror category, "Trans Ideology-Inspired Violent Extremism," cites an unsourced number: "Experts estimate" 50% of major non-gang school shootings since 2015 "involved or likely involved" trans ideology. It names no expert.
Sourcejustthenews.comTIVE_4_Pager_FINAL.pdf, p. 2Its longer model: the label does not apply to "all persons that are transgender, or their allies." "All three criteria must be met": seeing opposition as an existential threat, believing that justifies violence, and taking, inciting or promoting it.
Sourcestatic.itsyourgov.orgTIVE_8_Pager.pdf, p. 3Its own case list does not show those beliefs. For the 2022 plot against Justice Kavanaugh, its own account of the motive is anger over the leaked draft opinion on Roe v. Wade. Who a person is does not tell you why they acted.
Sourcestatic.itsyourgov.orgTIVE_8_Pager.pdf, p. 7The model's only source for calling its "extremists" often suicidal "and thereby predisposed to harm others" is a press release about puberty blockers. It offers no data on harm to others and counts transition surgery as self-harm.
Sourcestatic.itsyourgov.orgTIVE_8_Pager.pdf, p. 4The 2026 counterterror strategy vows to "identify their membership" of violent groups "whose ideology is anti-American, radically pro-transgender, and anarchist." Its one example is Kirk's killing. The court record does not support that link.
Sourcewhitehouse.gov2026-USCT-Strategy-1.pdf, p. 7The court record charges one man and names no accomplice or group. On trans rights, it records only his mother's account that he had grown more supportive of gay and trans rights. Millions hold that view. A view is not a violent group.
Sourcejustthenews.comTJR Information.pdf, p. 7In Kirk's killing, the engraved rounds carried no message about trans people. An early report claimed they did, but officials said the bulletin behind it "may not accurately reflect the messages on the ammunition."
Sourcekuow.orgstories/conservatives-falsely-accused-her-of-assassinating-charlie-kirk-it-started-with-dr-pepper-jokesThe strategy's own promise: "Our counterterrorism powers will not be used to target our fellow Americans who simply disagree with us." Supporting trans people's rights is disagreement, not violence.
Sourcewhitehouse.gov2026-USCT-Strategy-1.pdf, p. 4The Supreme Court: liability "may not be imposed merely because an individual belonged to a group, some members of which committed acts of violence." It requires proof that the individual "held a specific intent to further those illegal aims."
Sourcetile.loc.govusrep458886.pdf, p. 35The Attorney General's guidance on political violence counts radical gender ideology among extremist viewpoints. Its own footnote: "No investigation may be opened based solely on activities protected by the First Amendment."
Sourcedocs.house.govHHRG-119-JU00-20260211-SD032.pdf, p. 6The label already chills speech. A trans advocacy nonprofit whose monthly calls drew up to 100 people stopped holding public meetings and moved internal talk to Signal "because of the fear of how this could be leveraged against us."
Sourceunclosetedmedia.comp/trump-falsely-links-trans-peopleEven before the label, in a national probability survey in mid-2025, 55% of trans adults said they had taken steps to be less visible as LGBTQ people, against 24% of all LGBTQ adults.
Sourcemapresearch.orgbrief/new-survey-reveals-dramatic-changes-for-lgbtq-adults-since-november-2024Hate follows blame. Tracking global anti-LGBTQ+ hate posts for six months from mid-August 2025, the Institute for Strategic Dialogue found the three biggest spikes after the Annunciation shooting, Kirk's killing and Canada's Tumbler Ridge shooting.
Sourceisdglobal.orgdigital-dispatch/quantitative-analysis-anti-lgbtq-hate-tumbler-ridge-shootingOf 5,700+ mass shootings since 2013, five shooters were confirmed as trans, CNN reported. The same report described "preliminary" Justice Department talks on whether to "declare that people who are transgender are mentally ill" and disarm them.
Sourcecnn.com2025/09/04/politics/transgender-firearms-justice-department-second-amendmentThe American Psychiatric Association: "The term 'transgender' is not a psychiatric diagnosis." Gender dysphoria, which some trans people are diagnosed with, requires distress or impairment. None of its criteria concerns violence or risk to others.
Sourcepsychiatry.orgpatients-families/gender-dysphoria/what-is-gender-dysphoriaThe administration's own ATF wrote in May 2026 that federal law does not disarm those "simply 'afflicted with mental illness,'" which "could cover over 23% of the adult population." It takes an adjudication or involuntary commitment, not a diagnosis.
Sourcegovinfo.gov2026-09156.pdf, p. 4In July 2025, Attorney General Bondi faulted the law for disarming Americans with criminal histories "irrespective of whether they actually pose a threat." A ban by diagnosis would do that to people with no record at all.
Sourcejustice.govopa/pr/justice-department-publishes-proposed-rule-grant-relief-certain-individuals-precludedIn June 2026 the Supreme Court refused to deem marijuana users "categorically violent and dangerous without any further showing." A "broad power to designate any group as dangerous," it warned, could "quickly swallow" the Second Amendment.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-1234_g2bh.pdf, p. 22A ban by diagnosis would fall on people who sought care, and many already stay away: in the 2022 U.S. Transgender Survey, 24% of adults did not see a doctor when they needed to in the past year for fear of mistreatment.
Sourceustranssurvey.org2022-USTS-Early-Insights-Report_FINAL.pdf, p. 16Trans people are more often the ones harmed. In the CDC's 2023 survey, 40.1% of trans high school students had been bullied at school in the past year, against 20.3% of cis girls and 14.8% of cis boys; 25.3% missed school because they felt unsafe.
Sourcecdc.govmmwr/volumes/73/su/su7304a6.htmIn the federal crime-victim survey for 2017–2020, the violent victimization rate for trans people aged 16 and older was 51.5 per 1,000, "2.5 times the rate among cisgender persons" (20.5).
Sourcebjs.ojp.govvvsogi1720.pdf, p. 1The same survey's 2022–2023 data, analyzed by the Williams Institute: a violent victimization rate of 93.7 per 1,000 trans people, over four times the cisgender straight rate (21.1). Even the low end of its 95% confidence interval is over double.
Sourcewilliamsinstitute.law.ucla.eduAnti-LGBT-Violence-Feb-2025.pdf, p. 3Then the government stopped counting. The Bureau of Justice Statistics cut its survey's gender identity questions. Asked by the Williams Institute and 40+ groups to restore them, it cited an executive order: "these questions will not be added back."
Sourcereginfo.govpublic/do/DownloadDocumentAfter cutting gender identity from its crime-victim survey, the Justice Department offered $1 million in October 2026 to study gender dysphoria, its treatment and "the perpetration of violence." Its notice says the evidence "is limited."
Sourceojp.govnij-2026-172802.pdf, p. 3The federal survey that found trans people facing 2.5 to 4.4 times the violence can no longer count them, while officials point to trans people as a source of violence. Why stop measuring the harm while widening the suspicion?
What the evidence supports: investigate violence, threats, plans and material support, never views, identity or relationships. Withdraw the "radically pro-transgender" label and review any list or file built on it.
Tie no gun rule to gender identity or diagnosis; keep the requirement of a court finding or formal commitment. Handle danger one person at a time, through threat assessment, reporting and court orders. Restore the survey questions.
Pin no identity or ideology on a suspect before investigators establish it, and none on a whole group at all. Every attack has an attacker with a name, and the blame belongs there. Trans people are owed what everyone is owed: to answer only for their own acts.
End of thread · Back to the first post