A London primary school parent said there had been "cases of boys looking over the tops at girls on the toilet." The parent wanted floor-to-ceiling walls. A campaign against trans-inclusive toilets quoted it. The record shows who harmed those girls.
Sourcetransgendertrend.comgender-neutral-toilets-schoolsTransgender rightsRestroom privacy
Restroom access and privacy
How to protect children’s privacy without excluding transgender students.
Every parent hurts when a daughter is taunted. A rule that exposes daughters to assault would hurt far more. The answer is not to swap one harm for a worse one. It is to stop the boys and give every child privacy.
In Utah, after parents of girls she beat complained, officials searched a girl's school records back to kindergarten without telling her family. She was not trans. Other complaints cited athletes who didn't "look feminine enough." None were verified.
Sourcenews4jax.comnews/politics/2022/08/18/utah-officials-secretly-looked-into-female-athletes-genderWomen thought to look trans are already targeted. Texas Rep. Jessica González told the House: "It has happened to me personally in this very building just because I have short hair and I'm wearing a pantsuit."
Sourcejournals.house.texas.gov89C2DAY09CSUPPLEMENT.PDF, p. 7Asked if SB 8, Texas's bathroom law, had "anything" to protect such women, its House sponsor said: "No. This is here to protect biological females." González: "That's what I am." On bathroom policing: "That is not addressed in this bill."
Sourcejournals.house.texas.gov89C2DAY09CSUPPLEMENT.PDF, p. 5So who harms girls in toilets? The campaigners' own sources name them. In Wales in 2019, a parent said: "Boys are always speculating on whether girls are having their periods according to how long they take in the toilet."
Sourcetransgendertrend.comgender-neutral-toilets-schoolsIn the same accounts, girls stayed home over "period shaming" from boys. Not one account says the boys were trans. A trans pupil in the same article was told by a teacher she "could not use the toilets." The answer is to stop the boy.
Sourcetransgendertrend.comgender-neutral-toilets-schoolsSex Matters, which wants trans women out of women's toilets, names voyeurism among the most common sex crimes. The same page defends cubicles with gaps, where parents "can supervise children more easily," and calls full-height stalls "oppressive."
Sourcesex-matters.orgposts/updates/the-truth-about-toiletsGaps are how voyeurs film. In Guildford, a man filmed women and girls, one aged 11, "by inserting a camera phone under toilet doors and walls." A 15-year-old saw his phone under her stall. Women-only toilets did not stop him.
Sourceguildford-dragon.comnine-months-for-secretly-filming-women-and-girls-in-guildford-toiletsIn 2024, children changing after a swim saw "a mobile phone under the door" of their cubicle. It belonged to a former teacher, a 47-year-old man, later jailed for 16 years. Police found over 5,000 indecent images and videos of children.
Sourcecps.gov.uknorth-west/news/former-teacher-jailed-after-upskirting-incident-uncovered-his-secret-onlineSo who is served by a girl's stall that a phone can slide under, and by a rule that never names the boys?
Exclusion does not remove the danger; it moves the girl. Sex Matters says a pupil who says "I identify as a girl" "should not be allowed to use opposite-sex facilities." That leaves the boys' room, alone with the boys these campaigns call the danger.
Sourcesex-matters.orgposts/updates/the-truth-about-toiletsIn a 2019 study of 3,673 trans and nonbinary students in grades 7-12, trans girls whose school restroom or locker room use was restricted had 2.49 times the adjusted risk of sexual assault in the past year.
Sourcedoi.org10.1542/peds.2018-2902Where separation is carried all the way, in prisons, it is worse. Among male prisoners whose identity differs from their sex, 34.8% reported sexual victimization, against 3.5% of cis men: about ten times.
Sourcebjs.ojp.govcsvpri2324st.pdf, p. 8Schools already turn trans students away. In a national survey of 2,800 LGBTQ+ students about the 2023-24 school year, 41% of trans and gender-expansive students were "stopped or punished for using bathrooms aligned with their gender."
Sourceglisten.orgnscs2025Of those trans and gender-expansive students, 64% "reported avoiding school bathrooms altogether." A child who will not use the toilet all day is not being protected.
Sourceglisten.orgnscs2025In a 2021 U.S. survey of 12,596 trans and nonbinary people aged 13-24, 84.6% of trans girls and women sometimes or always avoided bathrooms. Across the sample, 66.9% held their urine and 38.3% avoided food or drink.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC12016251Among those who always avoided bathrooms, 61.7% avoided food or drink and 16.0% reported a urinary tract infection from it. Avoidance was tied to past-year suicide attempts (adjusted odds ratio 1.95, 95% CI 1.77-2.16).
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC12016251Does letting trans people use the right toilets raise crime? Researchers compared Massachusetts towns with and without trans-inclusive laws, before and after, using police records of incidents in restrooms, locker rooms and changing rooms.
Sourceescholarship.orgqt4rs4n6h0_noSplash_8740e92d7f24b6c89dbd4bd4d27fbbcb.pdf, p. 9Incidents did not rise. Where police notes gave detail, there was "no evidence of transgender people being either victims or perpetrators of crimes or of people pretending to be transgender in order to harm others."
Sourceescholarship.orgqt4rs4n6h0_noSplash_8740e92d7f24b6c89dbd4bd4d27fbbcb.pdf, p. 9The authors concluded that fears of more safety and privacy violations under such laws "are not empirically grounded." Whoever wants to bar a child from the girls' room must show the harm. The harm the record shows falls on the girl shut out.
Sourceescholarship.orgqt4rs4n6h0_noSplash_8740e92d7f24b6c89dbd4bd4d27fbbcb.pdf, p. 12The parent who complained said: "Making the toilets unisex isn't the issue for me." The issue was walls: "unisex toilets must have cubicle walls from floors to ceiling." Privacy for every child stops the peeping that exclusion never touches.
Sourcetransgendertrend.comgender-neutral-toilets-schoolsEngland's school building specification makes full height the standard from age 7: "Full height partitions shall have no gaps at all." Side gaps must not allow "malicious mobile phone use." Staff-only emergency release keeps rescue possible.
Sourceassets.publishing.service.gov.ukER-DFE-XX-XX-T-X-0201-Technical_Manual-A-C01.pdf, p. 110If a child collapses, the same specification has an answer: an emergency alarm with a pull cord reachable "from the floor," wired to a central control unit. It is required in accessible toilets; any school can fit one in every stall.
Sourceassets.publishing.service.gov.ukER-DFE-XX-XX-T-X-0201-Technical_Manual-A-C01.pdf, p. 319And schools must act on the boys. Law in England and Wales requires heads to set measures aimed at "preventing all forms of bullying among pupils," with rules and disciplinary penalties. That duty points at the boy who taunts, not at a trans girl.
Sourcelegislation.gov.ukukpga/2006/40/section/89What should be done: keep girls' toilets, and let trans girls use them. Never send a trans girl or woman into a boys' or men's room. Build full-height private stalls with an alarm and a staff emergency release.
Offer a single-user room to any child who wants one, as a choice and never as a rule for trans pupils. And act on every boy who taunts or peeps.
Every girl deserves a toilet where no one peers in and no one questions who she is. Whose daughter is safe under a rule that any stranger's doubt can set in motion?
End of thread · Back to the first post