Transgender rightsTexas SB 8

Texas SB 8 and access to public facilities

How Texas’s law affects restrooms, correctional housing, and services for survivors.

12 November 20269 min read69 numbered posts · 64 linked sourcesRead on Bluesky ↗Read on Threads ↗

2/69Link copied

That answer describes the law. It does not protect women; it makes them prove their sex, and it pushes trans women out of public life. Its two stated reasons, privacy and safety, are not supported by the record.

13/69Link copied

A trans woman using a women's restroom is a woman using a restroom. She invades no one's privacy and endangers no one.

19/69Link copied

A law whose sponsor blocked limits on strip searches and ID checks is not a privacy law. It is a screening law.

39/69Link copied

Restrictions go with more of that harm. In a 2019 study of 3,673 trans and nonbinary students in grades 7-12, trans girls whose school restroom or locker room use was restricted had 2.49 times the adjusted risk of sexual assault in the past year.

Sourcedoi.org10.1542/peds.2018-2902
49/69Link copied

Loudoun County, Va., became a national argument for laws like this. A 2022 special grand jury wrote that outrage focused there because the student "was labeled as gender fluid" and the district "had recently passed a transgender policy."

Sourceloudoun.govSpecialGrandJury
52/69Link copied

The grand jury found it "could have, and should have, been prevented," and blamed administrators who moved a student accused of assault without acting on what they knew. SB 8 does nothing to make schools act on such reports.

Sourceloudoun.govSpecialGrandJury
56/69Link copied

It shuts out people at higher risk. A 2020 meta-analysis of 85 articles (74 data sets, 49,966 trans participants) found trans people's intimate-partner-violence risk 1.66 times cisgender people's: 2.19 times for physical, 2.46 times for sexual.

Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC7427218
64/69Link copied

Trans people held with men fare worst. Among male prisoners whose identity differs from their sex, 34.8% reported sexual victimization, 31.1% by other prisoners, against 3.5% and 1.8% for cis men. SB 8 puts them there.

Sourcebjs.ojp.govcsvpri2324st.pdf, p. 8
67/69Link copied

Neither stated reason survives the record. What remains is driving trans people out of restrooms and shelters, and demanding papers from any woman who is questioned.

69/69Link copied

Women are protected by stopping the people who harm them, not by checking documents at the door. Trans women are among the women this law leaves less safe.

End of thread · Back to the first post