Transgender rightsMilitary service

The ban on transgender military service

The evidence behind military exclusion, and what reinstatement should restore.

12 November 202615 min read114 numbered posts · 105 linked sourcesRead on Bluesky ↗Read on Threads ↗

2/114Link copied

The government's reasons fail on its own record. Whoever would discharge people must prove harm, and it has not. No one should have to be exceptional to serve, and stating one's gender is not a lie. A trans person who meets the standards belongs in the military.

6/114Link copied

The government gives four reasons: honesty, readiness, cost and unit cohesion. None is supported by the record.

17/114Link copied

A policy that punishes people for saying who they are cannot then call them dishonest. Stating one's gender is honesty.

32/114Link copied

The memo treats trans people as a risk group, citing mental health statistics. That premise is the error. Being trans is not an illness or a defect, and the harm in those numbers comes from how trans people are treated.

48/114Link copied

A rule that counts hormones only against trans members targets the people, not the medicine.

58/114Link copied

That estimate assumed members could not time care around deployments. Even so, RAND found care would weigh on readiness only in "an especially unique military occupation" in demand, with "frequent, unpredicted mobilizations."

Sourcerand.orgRAND_RR1530.pdf, p. 63
71/114Link copied

Where some peers are hostile, the answer is to stop the hostility, not to remove its target. Equal service does not depend on colleagues' approval.

91/114Link copied

A "medical condition" sent through a misconduct process, and barred from medical review, is not being treated as medicine. It is being treated as an offense. Being trans is neither.

97/114Link copied

No one would ask a cis man to live as a woman for three years to keep his job. The waiver asks exactly that of every trans member.

113/114Link copied

What should be done: withdraw the order and the policy. Bar no one, serving or applying, for being trans, for a gender dysphoria diagnosis or history, or for transitioning. Let members start or continue transition care while serving.

114/114Link copied

Reinstate every separated member who wants to return, with rank, pay and records restored. Records can be fixed: under a 2025 settlement, Army veterans discharged less than fully honorably over their sexual orientation can apply as a group.

Sourcearmy.milarba

End of thread · Back to the first post