In 2021, an 11-year-old West Virginia girl wanted to run cross-country with her middle school team. The team cut no one. The state barred her because she is trans. In June 2026, the Supreme Court upheld that law. Nothing in the record justified it.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 46Transgender rightsSchool sports
Trans students and school sports
What the research and court records say, and what school sports mean to students.
The courts refer to her as B.P.J. Under a court order, she competed while the case continued, and she won the state title in girls' shot put.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 12The majority wrote that every trans girl who wins a race "takes the gold medal away from a female athlete." That sentence assumes she is not a girl. She is. A girl who wins her event has taken nothing that belonged to another girl.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 21The same opinion states that "every athlete who makes a team takes a roster spot from another athlete." Competition works that way for every girl. The law removes only trans girls for it.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 32Her competing is described as taking a place; removing her before a single race is described as fairness. In this record, the only place lost was the one the law took from her.
West Virginia is not alone. By the end of 2025, about 382,800 trans youth aged 13-17, roughly half of all trans teens in the U.S., lived in the 29 states restricting their school sports, the Williams Institute estimates.
Sourcewilliamsinstitute.law.ucla.edupublications/anti-trans-legislation-youthA 2025 executive order, titled "Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports," extends the exclusion nationally. The "men" in its title are trans girls and women, including children like her. It calls their inclusion "demeaning, unfair, and dangerous."
Sourcefederalregister.govdocuments/2025/02/11/2025-02513/keeping-men-out-of-womens-sportsThe order cites no data and no study for any of this.
Sourcegovinfo.govcontent/pkg/DCPD-202500229/html/DCPD-202500229.htmThe numbers are small. Asked at a 2024 Senate hearing how many trans athletes were known among 510,000 college athletes, NCAA president Charlie Baker answered: "Less than 10."
Sourcegovinfo.govCHRG-118shrg61196.pdf, p. 35Vetoing Utah's ban in 2022, Gov. Spencer Cox counted "4 transgender kids playing high school sports in Utah" out of 75,000, and "1 transgender student playing girls sports": kids not "winning trophies or taking scholarships."
Sourcegovernor.utah.govpress/gov-cox-signs-21-bills-vetoes-one-bill-of-the-2022-general-legislative-sessionCox quoted Utah's school sports association: "we have not had any complaints from any other students or families or school administrators." Cox's conclusion: "Rarely has so much fear and anger been directed at so few."
Sourcegovernor.utah.govpress/gov-cox-signs-21-bills-vetoes-one-bill-of-the-2022-general-legislative-sessionWest Virginia's governor, asked after signing its ban for "one example of a transgender child trying to get an unfair advantage," answered: "No, I can't really tell you one."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250912160838407_volume7.pdf, p. 254The state education department's general counsel wrote of the bill: "it seems like much ado about nothing. I don't think any of it is necessary."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250912160838407_volume7.pdf, p. 220The district court found the record "abundantly clear": "at the time it passed the law, West Virginia had no known instance of any transgender person playing school sports."
Sourceca4.uscourts.gov231078.p.pdf, p. 30Justice Sotomayor named the contradiction. The majority credits the legislature's fear that trans girls are "large enough to pose an existential threat to girls' sports," yet holds them "too small to be protected by the equal protection clause."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 64These laws rest on three claims: that including trans girls is unfair, that it is dangerous, and that it takes places from other girls. Each is used to take children off their teams. None survives the record.
The first claim is fairness. Girls' teams have never set a strength limit; no girl is cut for being tall, fast or strong. Physical ability is not a reason to exclude any girl. A trans girl belongs on her team on the same terms as every other girl.
Before the law, a trans girl could join her team if her school found "fair competition" unaffected; on appeal, the commission weighed "age," "athletic experience," "strength, size, [and] speed." Individual review existed.
Sourceca4.uscourts.gov231078.p.pdf, p. 9The law's "entire purpose," Justice Sotomayor wrote, "was to eliminate the possibility of allowing any exception."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 63The IOC's 2021 framework, an endocrinologist told the court, sees no inherent reason to treat trans women's traits as "any more of an 'unfair' advantage than the advantages that already exist among different women athletes."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250912160809049_volume4.pdf, p. 274The fairness evidence does not show what it is cited for. For its claim that hormones leave an advantage, Idaho's law cites one study: knee strength in 11 untrained adults who went through male puberty. It bars every trans girl in the state.
Sourcepubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov31794605That study, Justice Sotomayor noted, "was later altered after peer review, and the conclusions the legislature [had] relied upon were removed." It "did not involve transgender athletes at all."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 68Another study's author asked Idaho's governor to veto the law, explaining that its findings "had misrepresented her work."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 68A 2026 meta-analysis pooled 50 studies of 6,099 people. It found trans women's strength and aerobic capacity comparable to cisgender women's, and concluded the evidence "does not support theories of inherent athletic advantages."
Sourcebjsm.bmj.comcontent/60/3/198The majority deferred to the view that trans girls "still retain a physical advantage after taking puberty blockers and hormones." Even on its own terms, that view lacks evidence.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 29For its view of the science, the majority cited a study published after oral argument. "That study is not in the record before the Court," Justice Sotomayor wrote.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 68In B.P.J., "both sides cited authorities agreeing that the driver of the most significant sex-based differences in athletic performance is differing levels of circulating testosterone." The law never asks about testosterone.
Sourceca4.uscourts.gov231078.p.pdf, p. 28"The undisputed evidence shows B.P.J. has never gone through the Tanner 2 stage," the appeals court found; she began puberty blockers at its start. The state barred her anyway.
Sourceca4.uscourts.gov231078.p.pdf, p. 28The appeals court found that the law's "sole purpose" and "sole effect" is "to prevent transgender girls from playing on girls teams."
Sourceca4.uscourts.gov231078.p.pdf, p. 8In a 2026 Washington case, one of the experts for the side seeking exclusion acknowledged "very limited research on how puberty blockers affect physical fitness and none on sports performance."
Sourcestorage.courtlistener.comgov.uscourts.wawd.363908.58.0.pdf, p. 14That expert, Gregory Brown, also testified for West Virginia. Asked for data on how young trans girls perform, Brown answered: "I am not aware of any data analyzing trans girls."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250912160829202_volume6.pdf, p. 196Brown cited a sports-medicine consensus statement but left out its key point, that a testosterone limit for trans women athletes "is a justifiable threshold." Asked why: "I disagree with that key point." "I cited the information that I agree with."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250912160844610_volume8.pdf, p. 152What has been measured does not show the assumed advantage. Ciancia et al. (2024) followed 26 trans girls who began puberty suppression early in puberty (Tanner stage 2-3). Their grip strength stayed below the cisgender-girl average.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC12312191Each child was scored against both boys' and girls' norms. When hormones began, their grip strength "was more similar to cisgender girls than to cisgender boys." If blockers left a male advantage, this comparison would show it. It did not.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC12312191Arizona officials cited Tack (2018) to claim "medical suppression of male puberty" leaves a strength gap. Tack's trans girls began treatment late in puberty (Tanner stage 4-5). Even so, they lost 2.2 kg of lean mass and grip-strength Z scores fell.
Sourcepubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov29672753In a 2024 study (Hamilton et al.), trained trans women athletes scored lower than cis women on aerobic capacity per kilogram: 45.1 vs 54.1. Should the higher-scoring cis women be excluded? No. Ability differences are no ground for exclusion.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC11137468Its authors wrote that the results "should caution against precautionary bans and sport eligibility exclusions that are not based on sport-specific (or sport-relevant) research." The school bans are exactly that.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC11137468The fairness claim fails: it treats a girl as a boy, and the evidence behind it does not show what it is cited for. On that basis, girls are being taken off their teams.
The second claim is safety. Every girl deserves to be safe in sport. The majority said inclusion "can put women and girls at significant risk of injuries," but the opinion cites no injury data for this.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 17West Virginia's own lawyers told the appeals court that their defense of excluding B.P.J. "doesn't focus on safety."
Sourceca4.uscourts.gov231078.p.pdf, p. 26The law's only option for her, a boys' team, means "sharing the field with boys who are larger, stronger, and faster than her," the appeals court found. A law said to prevent injury sends a girl toward it.
Sourceca4.uscourts.gov231078.p.pdf, p. 35In August 2026, a federal court in Washington state observed that the ruling "does not identify what evidence supported these statements." It found the record "inconclusive as to whether transgender girls increase the risk of physical injury."
Sourcestorage.courtlistener.comgov.uscourts.wawd.363908.58.0.pdf, p. 38The evidence offered there was girls' general injury rates, high "even without transgender athletes competing," and a rugby concussion model, "not a WIAA sport." Neither expert would say inclusion "necessarily" raised the risk.
Sourcestorage.courtlistener.comgov.uscourts.wawd.363908.58.0.pdf, p. 40Washington state has barred discrimination against trans students in school sports for 20 years. Its state schools office reports no official complaint "regarding any particular transgender student's athletic participation."
Sourcestorage.courtlistener.comgov.uscourts.wawd.363908.58.0.pdf, p. 41Los Angeles schools adopted a trans-inclusive policy in 2004, deciding competitive sports case by case. Nine years later, a California Senate analysis recorded: "The LAUSD reports no issues, problems or lawsuits as a result of the policy."
Sourceleginfo.ca.govpub/13-14/bill/asm/ab_1251-1300/ab_1266_cfa_20130610_160930_sen_comm.htmlCalifornia's school sports federation had included trans students as its practice "for several years," the same analysis noted, and "receives very few requests for assistance by school districts."
Sourceleginfo.ca.govpub/13-14/bill/asm/ab_1251-1300/ab_1266_cfa_20130610_160930_sen_comm.htmlNational data show who is unsafe at school. In the CDC's 2023 high school survey, 40.1% of trans students had been bullied at school in the past year, against 20.3% of cisgender girls.
Sourcecdc.govmmwr/volumes/73/su/su7304a6.htmIn the past month, 25.3% of trans students had missed school because they felt unsafe, against 14.9% of cisgender girls. Both comparisons are the survey's adjusted estimates.
Sourcecdc.govmmwr/volumes/73/su/su7304a6.htmThe same case shows how the safety claim is used. A mother and daughter sued over an allegation about one student at a girls' wrestling match. Their Supreme Court application, filed by Alliance Defending Freedom, calls that student "male" throughout.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20261002172555997_KMK v WIAA SCOTUS Application with Appendix.pdf, p. 17They did not seek protection from that student alone. They sought notice of every trans athlete the daughter might face, in any sport. The Ninth Circuit held that this "goes well beyond what is reasonably necessary to protect" her from that student.
Sourcecdn.ca9.uscourts.gov26-5488.pdf, p. 9A complaint about one person's conduct concerns that person. This one was directed at every trans girl, on the same premise the bans rest on: that a trans girl is a boy. The safety claim has no evidence behind it; it is used to single out trans girls.
The third claim is that trans girls take other girls' places. A girl who earns her spot takes no one's. In March 2026, the Justice Department alleged that a Minnesota trans girl "has displaced" girls. It named no girl who lost a place.
Sourcejustice.govcrt/media/1433251/dlSix months earlier, in a Minnesota softball case, a federal court found no showing that a trans girl's play was likely to cost any member of the plaintiff group a roster spot, an award or a scholarship.
Sourcestorage.courtlistener.comgov.uscourts.mnd.225310.134.0.pdf, p. 57The court added that the group's members "are not at risk of losing their ability to participate, a fact FAU acknowledges."
Sourcestorage.courtlistener.comgov.uscourts.mnd.225310.134.0.pdf, p. 64At one meet, B.P.J. placed 123rd of 150. West Virginia's answer: she "displaced 27 participants," exactly the number who finished behind her. By that measure, every runner displaces everyone she beats.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250912160934198_volume10.pdf, p. 106On her own team, the county stipulated, "No student was cut from or otherwise not permitted to participate on the cross-country team as a result of B.P.J.'s participation."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250912160934198_volume10.pdf, p. 108In running, B.P.J. was "too slow to compete in the track events" two years in a row. When the state cited her shot put gains, the appeals court doubted that "a young athlete's ordinary, year-over-year athletic improvement" was cause to remove her.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250912160934198_volume10.pdf, p. 384West Virginia itself conceded in the lower court that it has no interest "in protecting one girl's ranking in any competition or 'in ensuring that cisgender girls do not lose ever to transgender girls.'"
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 52A "wins" tally filed with the Supreme Court by the Independent Women's Law Center, drawn from the website HeCheated, counts only events trans athletes entered, at every level. It never counts all girls' events, so it cannot show how often girls lose.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20250919202808549_24-43 BPJ IWLC Amicus 9.19.25.pdf, p. 15It also counts a trans girl's win as a loss to other girls, the same premise again. No record here shows a girl displaced. The only places lost are the ones these laws take.
Girls do lose places, to underinvestment. "High-school girls still have 1.3 million fewer opportunities to play sports than do high-school boys," the National Women's Law Center told the Court. In West Virginia: 21,502 boys, 16,212 girls.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20251117170031613_2025.11.17 - NWLC SCOTUS FINAL.pdf, p. 37Those disparities "do far more to deprive girls and women of equal athletic opportunities than the participation of transgender athletes ever has or could," the center wrote. Excluding a handful of trans girls adds none.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov20251117170031613_2025.11.17 - NWLC SCOTUS FINAL.pdf, p. 37The ruling also put the burden of proof on the excluded girl. It upheld the ban because the record did not "definitively establish" the state was wrong. Under the Court's 1996 precedent, that burden "rests entirely on the State."
Sourcetile.loc.govusrep518515.pdf, p. 19The majority went further. Even if some trans girls on blockers or hormones keep no physical advantage, it wrote, "that empirical claim would not alter the equal protection conclusion." The evidence was never allowed to decide the case.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 29The majority defined the state's goal as letting "biological women and girls" compete only against each other. A goal defined as the exclusion itself is met by any exclusion. Justice Sotomayor wrote that this "misrepresents" the state's interest.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 52The ruling does not require any state to exclude trans girls. Its first footnote leaves that open: "Nothing in this opinion is intended to decide that question."
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 8The majority pointed to NCAA and U.S. Olympic & Paralympic Committee rules. Both changed "after the President issued Executive Order No. 14201," which threatened "to take away federal funding from any educational program" that included trans girls.
Sourcesupremecourt.gov24-43_2b35.pdf, p. 68When the Justice Department sued California to force exclusion, a federal court dismissed the case for good on Aug. 31, 2026. Title IX, the school sex-discrimination law, "did not clearly impose any such rule as a condition of federal funding."
Sourceadmin.smc.eduUS-v-CIF-Order.pdf, p. 20In April 2025, the Agriculture Department froze Maine's funds over trans athletes, saying this "does not impact federal feeding programs." The court found it cut off accounts paying for children's meals and ordered the funds released "immediately."
Sourcestorage.courtlistener.comgov.uscourts.med.67828.12.0.pdf, p. 59The bans take sport from the children who need it most. In Minnesota's 2022 survey of over 10,000 trans and gender-diverse students, 44.5% of those in any sport had elevated depressive symptoms, vs 58.4% of those in none. Anxiety: 50.5% vs 63.7%.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC13426070The benefit held where risk was highest. In the highest-risk subgroups of students facing bias-based bullying, those on teams had, on average, rates of elevated depressive symptoms 19.0 points lower and of elevated anxiety 21.2 points lower.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC13426070Colorado's 2019 student survey agrees: trans students who played on three or more teams had lower odds of depression than those on none (adjusted odds ratio 0.32, 95% CI 0.15-0.69).
Sourceonlinelibrary.wiley.comdoi/full/10.1002/pits.22792Trans girls describe the same benefits. A study of 294 trans girls in high school found they play for physical and mental health, fun, friendships and gender affirmation.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC10835156Of 141 responses giving reasons for not playing, 37 (26%) involved knowing or fearing they would have to use teams or facilities that did not match their gender, the condition these bans impose.
Sourcepmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govarticles/PMC10835156Many are already shut out. In The Trevor Project's 2025 survey of 3,758 trans, nonbinary and gender-expansive students, 33% reported being unable to play on a team that matched their gender.
Sourcethetrevorproject.orgresearch-briefs/school-experiences-and-outcomes-among-transgender-nonbinary-and-gender-expansive-young-peopleThat rate is lower where schools have a policy. In GLSEN's 2021 survey, 18.5% of trans and nonbinary students in schools with a supportive policy were kept off the team matching their gender, against 37.9% in schools without one.
Sourceglisten.org2021-National-School-Climate-Survey-Full-Report.pdf, p. 24Enforcement reaches every girl. Under Idaho's law, when a student's sex is disputed, the school asks for a statement from her doctor based on her reproductive anatomy, genes or testosterone. Any girl can be disputed.
Sourcelegislature.idaho.govstatutesrules/idstat/Title33/T33CH62/SECT33-6203Utah's legislature recorded that a state school board member posted a student athlete's photo and "questioned the student's gender publicly and without evidence." The student faced "threats of violence."
Sourcele.utah.gov~2024/bills/hbillenr/HCR018.htmAfter parents of two girls she beat complained, Utah's high school association searched a girl's school records back to kindergarten without telling her family. She was not trans. Others came "when an athlete doesn't look feminine enough."
Sourcenews4jax.comnews/politics/2022/08/18/utah-officials-secretly-looked-into-female-athletes-genderThe Ninth Circuit found that keeping one wrestler from ever facing a trans opponent would require schools to "collect new, invasive information from an unknown number of students." A ban requires the same sorting of every girl.
Sourcecdn.ca9.uscourts.gov26-5488.pdf, p. 10Privacy does not require a ban. Washington's school sports association says "any student who desires a greater degree of privacy for changing" should be given options, with no proof of gender required.
Sourceassets-rst7.rschooltoday.comGender-Diversity-Toolkit_2024.pdfPractice-only access is not inclusion. A Utah trans girl said that if she could practice but not compete, she would not run cross-country at all: "That is not being part of the team."
Sourceacluutah.orgaclu_ut_-_hb_11_-_motion_for_summary_judgment_1.pdf, p. 22In 2023, the UN Human Rights Committee faulted U.S. state laws that "forbid transgender individuals from using restrooms or from participating in school sports consistent with their gender identity," and urged their repeal.
Sourcedigitallibrary.un.orgrecord/4029375What should be done: repeal these bans and restore eligibility by gender identity, not practice-only access or assignment to boys' teams. Repeal sex screening and medical-proof rules, and protect every student's privacy.
End the funding cutoffs and lawsuits against states and schools that include trans students; courts have found Title IX does not clearly require exclusion. A trans girl's place on her team is her own. No child should have to prove she belongs.
End of thread · Back to the first post